UA93 was shot down

Overview

There is a theory that UA93, the plane which crashed in Pennsylvania on 9/11, was shot down by the US military – contradicting the official story that the passengers, having learned of the other airplane-based attacks via cellphone, took over the command cabin and crashed the plane rather than allowing it to be used against a target.

Discussion

There is some evidence for this, e.g. eyewitness claims. Further documentation needed just so we have all the claims/arguments in one place.

Need Facts

• Links to recordings of cellphone conversations (which at least one site claims have not been made available)
• Eyewitness claims of an apparent missile strike on UA93
• Any other arguments used to support this theory

Counterarguments

• This would indicate an arguably proper response to the situation, i.e. something along the lines of the military scrambling jets to intercept, the aircraft not responding to hails, and the military deciding – given circumstances in DC and NYC – to shoot down a hijacked civilian airliner over sparsely inhabited territory rather than risk its use as yet a third missile. If so, why hide the true story?
  • There is a Vanity Fair article which sheds considerable light on what probably happened, without directly addressing the issue of why the physical evidence suggests a shoot-down. (Possibly that resemblance is because of the difference between this crash and all prior crashes: whoever was in charge was trying to crash, and hence may have aimed the plane more or less straight down.)
• It seems clear that airline passengers are certainly willing to act to foil terrorist plots. Prior to 9/11, most airplane-based terrorism was best handled by negotiation, and passengers were best advised to go along calmly and quietly in order to prevent unnecessary deaths. In the wake of 9/11, where it is well known that the stakes can consist of much more than the airplane and its occupants, people have begun fighting back:
  • 2002-02-16 The Shoe Bomber's World
  • 2003-05-29 Stabbing would-be hijacker subdued
  • 2006-12-26 Passengers thwart Russian plane hijacking