Difference between revisions of "Pocketing the question"
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
(Created page with "<hide> page type::article thing type::rhetorical deception category:rhetorical deceptions category:terms of convenience </hide> ==About== [[Pocketing the question...") |
|||
| (2 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
<hide> | <hide> | ||
[[page type::article]] | [[page type::article]] | ||
| − | [[thing type::rhetorical | + | [[thing type::rhetorical distraction]] |
| − | [[category:rhetorical | + | [[category:rhetorical distraction]] |
[[category:terms of convenience]] | [[category:terms of convenience]] | ||
</hide> | </hide> | ||
| Line 8: | Line 8: | ||
[[Pocketing the question]] is a [[rhetorical deception]] in which a question is supposedly answered, but in fact the answer leaves one or more other questions unasked. The "explainer" is, in this case, moving the question around enough that you don't notice that it has not really been answered -- having been deftly hidden in the explainer's (metaphorical) pocket. | [[Pocketing the question]] is a [[rhetorical deception]] in which a question is supposedly answered, but in fact the answer leaves one or more other questions unasked. The "explainer" is, in this case, moving the question around enough that you don't notice that it has not really been answered -- having been deftly hidden in the explainer's (metaphorical) pocket. | ||
===Begging the Question=== | ===Begging the Question=== | ||
| − | This is equivalent to one common (but apparently inaccurate) usage of the phrase "[[begging the question]]", in the sense that the answer provided to one question "begs" for another question to be asked. | + | This is equivalent to one common (but apparently inaccurate) usage of the phrase "[[begging the question]]", in the sense that the answer provided to one question "begs" for another question to be asked. (The phrase "begging the question" ''traditionally'' refers to [[wikipedia:begging the question|a form of circular argument]].) |
Latest revision as of 12:25, 3 August 2021
About
Pocketing the question is a rhetorical deception in which a question is supposedly answered, but in fact the answer leaves one or more other questions unasked. The "explainer" is, in this case, moving the question around enough that you don't notice that it has not really been answered -- having been deftly hidden in the explainer's (metaphorical) pocket.
Begging the Question
This is equivalent to one common (but apparently inaccurate) usage of the phrase "begging the question", in the sense that the answer provided to one question "begs" for another question to be asked. (The phrase "begging the question" traditionally refers to a form of circular argument.)