What is good about money?
From Talk:Money
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
Revision as of 18 July 2020 at 23:50.
The highlighted comment was created in this revision.
The highlighted comment was created in this revision.
Morbius has posed these questions:
- What good things does money make possible?
- What becomes exceeding difficult without it?
- Why are there no large, complex, highly-capable nonmonetary societies?
(On that last: you might well argue that LCHC societies are not a Good Thing. But you still have to contend with the absence of any nonmonetary examples.)
There are lots of ways to take that question... mainly combinations of the following attributes, I think:
- (1) - (a) things that wouldn't work without money, or (b) things that money makes easier but which might be done other ways?
- (2) - (a) specific projects, or (b) general areas of social good?
My answers for each possible combination:
- 1a2a: really can't think of anything, suspect there isn't anything
- 1b2a: I can only think of classes of project -- basically any project where one person grasps the value of something, would find it very difficult to persuade anyone else of its value, and has the necessary money to pursue it themself.
- 1a2b: I'll concede that there might be some things in this category, but have not been able to think of anything.
- 1b2b: initiatives along the general lines of "block grants", where such projects actually do provide benefit; research grants, possibly? I could probably list more, but I'm skeptical that money (at least in its present form) actually makes these things easier than possible alternatives.