Difference between revisions of "Transnegation"
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
| (11 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
| + | <hide> | ||
| + | [[page type::article]] | ||
| + | [[thing type::advocacy]] | ||
| + | </hide> | ||
==About== | ==About== | ||
| − | + | [[Transnegation]] is a form of [[social stagnationism]] which has the ''net effect'' of needlessly working against the [[social right]]s or equality of [[transgender]] people, generally by denying that [[transgenderness]] is really a thing. It is not ''necessarily'' malicious in intent, and is often couched in sympathetic terms, though the reasoning always seems to point towards unspoken [[transmisia]] as a root cause. Where it appears sympathetic, it is typically based on [[disinformation]]. | |
| + | |||
| + | Transnegation takes a variety of forms. | ||
| + | |||
| + | As overtly religious arguments lost traction over the late 2010s (having shed most of their credibility during their [[homomisia|war on gay people]]), [[social stagnationist]]s have found more subtle ways to lend their ideas plausibility and have reoriented their focus toward criticism of [[transgenderness]], which lags behind [[homosexuality]] in its popular acceptance. | ||
| + | |||
| + | There are also a growing number of self-identified [[feminist]]s and "pro-woman" advocates (not necessarily feminists) who represent themselves as believing that trans rights represent a threat to women's safety. Since these people do not represent the majority of feminists (or even the majority of [[cisgender]] women), they have become referred to as "trans-exclusionary radical feminists" or "[[TERF]]s". | ||
| + | |||
| + | The TERF branch of anti-trans advocacy most notably represents a growing political force [[/UK|in the UK]], where trans rights have been well established for some time but legal improvements and updates are needed in order to accommodate improved understanding. | ||
| + | ===Pages=== | ||
| + | * [[/JKR]]: author J.K. Rowling has been a heavy promoter of anti-trans beliefs and sentiments | ||
| + | * [[/UK]]: anti-trans advocacy in the UK | ||
| − | |||
===Related=== | ===Related=== | ||
| − | * [[TERF]] ideology heavily promotes | + | * ''[[Irreversible Damage: The Transgender Craze Seducing Our Daughters]]'': a book |
| − | * [[ | + | * [[TERF]] ideology heavily promotes anti-trans beliefs |
| + | * [[Truscum]] advocate a form of [[gender exclusionism]] which holds that physical dysphoria and a wish for medical intervention are both requirements for [[transgenderness]]. | ||
| + | * [[Rapid onset gender dysphoria]]: a questionable phenomenon often cited by anti-trans advocates as fact | ||
| + | |||
==Advocates== | ==Advocates== | ||
| − | + | People who promote anti-trans beliefs include: | |
* [[Alice Dreger]] | * [[Alice Dreger]] | ||
* [[Graham Linehan]] UK | * [[Graham Linehan]] UK | ||
| Line 13: | Line 30: | ||
* [[Maya Forstater]]: UK TERF, repeats myths | * [[Maya Forstater]]: UK TERF, repeats myths | ||
* [[Paul McHugh]]: US; bad science; gender fundamentalist | * [[Paul McHugh]]: US; bad science; gender fundamentalist | ||
| − | * [[Ray Blanchard]]: US/CA; bad science; says homosexuality is "not normal" | + | * [[Ray Blanchard]]: US/CA; bad science; also says homosexuality is "not normal" |
| + | ==Examples== | ||
| + | * '''2018-04-05''' [https://twitter.com/Ankhassa/status/981905908270813184 Ankhassa@Twitter] "There is no need for any other definition for a woman apart from "woman". Its a description which has been representative for thousands of years. As has "man". If it doesn't suit you why on earth would you claim be one?" -- The last tweet in a long discussion that began with a link to a YouTube video entitled "Transgender Women Aren't 'Women'" | ||
==Links== | ==Links== | ||
* CWRE: {{l/cwre|Myths/transgendrity}}: popular myths about transgenderness | * CWRE: {{l/cwre|Myths/transgendrity}}: popular myths about transgenderness | ||
{{links/smw}} | {{links/smw}} | ||
Revision as of 19:59, 13 November 2020
About
Transnegation is a form of social stagnationism which has the net effect of needlessly working against the social rights or equality of transgender people, generally by denying that transgenderness is really a thing. It is not necessarily malicious in intent, and is often couched in sympathetic terms, though the reasoning always seems to point towards unspoken transmisia as a root cause. Where it appears sympathetic, it is typically based on disinformation.
Transnegation takes a variety of forms.
As overtly religious arguments lost traction over the late 2010s (having shed most of their credibility during their war on gay people), social stagnationists have found more subtle ways to lend their ideas plausibility and have reoriented their focus toward criticism of transgenderness, which lags behind homosexuality in its popular acceptance.
There are also a growing number of self-identified feminists and "pro-woman" advocates (not necessarily feminists) who represent themselves as believing that trans rights represent a threat to women's safety. Since these people do not represent the majority of feminists (or even the majority of cisgender women), they have become referred to as "trans-exclusionary radical feminists" or "TERFs".
The TERF branch of anti-trans advocacy most notably represents a growing political force in the UK, where trans rights have been well established for some time but legal improvements and updates are needed in order to accommodate improved understanding.
Pages
- /JKR: author J.K. Rowling has been a heavy promoter of anti-trans beliefs and sentiments
- /UK: anti-trans advocacy in the UK
Related
- Irreversible Damage: The Transgender Craze Seducing Our Daughters: a book
- TERF ideology heavily promotes anti-trans beliefs
- Truscum advocate a form of gender exclusionism which holds that physical dysphoria and a wish for medical intervention are both requirements for transgenderness.
- Rapid onset gender dysphoria: a questionable phenomenon often cited by anti-trans advocates as fact
Advocates
People who promote anti-trans beliefs include:
- Alice Dreger
- Graham Linehan UK
- J.K. Rowling: UK TERF, supports Maya Forstater, repeats myths
- Maya Forstater: UK TERF, repeats myths
- Paul McHugh: US; bad science; gender fundamentalist
- Ray Blanchard: US/CA; bad science; also says homosexuality is "not normal"
Examples
- 2018-04-05 Ankhassa@Twitter "There is no need for any other definition for a woman apart from "woman". Its a description which has been representative for thousands of years. As has "man". If it doesn't suit you why on earth would you claim be one?" -- The last tweet in a long discussion that began with a link to a YouTube video entitled "Transgender Women Aren't 'Women'"
Links
- CWRE: Myths/transgendrity: popular myths about transgenderness
Related
- 2020/10/02 [L..T] Young trans men share brutal accounts of conversion therapy camps, where they were abused and forced to carry heavy rocks “...in June, J.K. Rowling liked a tweet from a Canadian anti-trans organisation called We The Females opposing a proposed law in Canada that would ban conversion therapy for LGBT+ youth, including trans kids. [..] Like other anti-trans organisations, We The Females propose that trans youth should be subjected to “gender-critical therapy”, to deter or prevent them from transitioning. Gender-critical feminists often claim that affirming therapists railroad youth. ”
- 2020/07/27 [L..T] Just an ordinary TERF talking about biology Myers dissects some bizarre arguments from @lissyboops, who is apparently of the TERF persuasion.
- 2018/02/15 [L..T] Transgender Women Aren't "Women" "I wanted to talk about the fact that I personally find it kind of offensive when transgender people don't own the fact that they're trans." Video is Tweeted, and much debate ensues.