Straw Vulcan

From Issuepedia
Jump to: navigation, search


The straw Vulcan is a straw man characterization of rationality that is used as an argument for the superiority of supposedly rational methods of thinking.

It is a conceptual fallacy in that it misconceptualizes the idea of rationality by making the assumption that rationality can only operate on the basis of certainties, and that it is therefore irrational to trust a hunch or feeling – even if one has extensive past experience indicating that hunches in similar circumstances are reliable.

It also depends somewhat on the calmness-rationality fallacy, in which an appearance of calmness (especially in the face of potentially upsetting information) is taken as indicating greater rationality.