Difference between revisions of "Appeal to shame"
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
(shaming) |
|||
| Line 7: | Line 7: | ||
</hide> | </hide> | ||
==About== | ==About== | ||
| − | An [[appeal to shame]] is a form of [[appeal to negative emotion]] in which the target is encouraged to feel shameful for holding the views for which they are arguing. This is typically done by ascribing false motives to the target, or motives which may seem "obviously" true despite not being true at all. | + | An [[appeal to shame]] (aka ''[[shaming]]'') is a form of [[appeal to negative emotion]] in which the target is encouraged to feel shameful for holding the views for which they are arguing. This is typically done by ascribing false motives to the target, or motives which may seem "obviously" true despite not being true at all. |
==Related== | ==Related== | ||
* The [[appeal to shame]] is very similar to the [[appeal to guilt]]. The difference (tentatively) is that "shame" is more about the fear of social disapproval, while "guilt" is an appeal to one's own [[moral]] sense. | * The [[appeal to shame]] is very similar to the [[appeal to guilt]]. The difference (tentatively) is that "shame" is more about the fear of social disapproval, while "guilt" is an appeal to one's own [[moral]] sense. | ||
==Validity== | ==Validity== | ||
The "appeal to shame" may be acceptable as a way of ''shaming'' an opponent into accepting an otherwise-valid argument when logic and reason have failed; see [[rhetorical deception/valid uses]] for further discussion. | The "appeal to shame" may be acceptable as a way of ''shaming'' an opponent into accepting an otherwise-valid argument when logic and reason have failed; see [[rhetorical deception/valid uses]] for further discussion. | ||
Revision as of 10:05, 18 December 2016
About
An appeal to shame (aka shaming) is a form of appeal to negative emotion in which the target is encouraged to feel shameful for holding the views for which they are arguing. This is typically done by ascribing false motives to the target, or motives which may seem "obviously" true despite not being true at all.
Related
- The appeal to shame is very similar to the appeal to guilt. The difference (tentatively) is that "shame" is more about the fear of social disapproval, while "guilt" is an appeal to one's own moral sense.
Validity
The "appeal to shame" may be acceptable as a way of shaming an opponent into accepting an otherwise-valid argument when logic and reason have failed; see rhetorical deception/valid uses for further discussion.