Difference between revisions of "Fake explanation"
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
(3 more examples, link update, and further Yudkowski reading) |
|||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
| − | + | <hide> | |
| − | [[category:rhetorical | + | [[thing type::rhetorical deception]] |
| + | [[category:rhetorical deception]] | ||
| + | </hide> | ||
| + | ==About== | ||
| + | A [[fake explanation]] is anything which ''sounds'' like an explanation, or is offered as an explanation, but which does not offer any further understanding even if it might be true. | ||
Many [[fake explanation]]s are also [[curiosity stopper]]s. | Many [[fake explanation]]s are also [[curiosity stopper]]s. | ||
| Line 7: | Line 11: | ||
* The question-and-answer pair "What makes it go? Energy!", found in an elementary school science textbook, was derided by the late [[Nobel Prize]]-winning physicist [[Richard Feynman]] as being utterly useless as an explanation. | * The question-and-answer pair "What makes it go? Energy!", found in an elementary school science textbook, was derided by the late [[Nobel Prize]]-winning physicist [[Richard Feynman]] as being utterly useless as an explanation. | ||
* [[Phlogiston]] was a hypothetical substance contained within certain materials and whose release was believed to explain processes such as combustion and the rusting of metals, which are now understood as [[oxidation]]. {{wpcite|Phlogiston theory}} | * [[Phlogiston]] was a hypothetical substance contained within certain materials and whose release was believed to explain processes such as combustion and the rusting of metals, which are now understood as [[oxidation]]. {{wpcite|Phlogiston theory}} | ||
| − | * [[Luminiferous aether]] was a hypothetical medium believed to be necessary for the transmission of electromagnetic energy. It was proved nonexistent by the [[ | + | * [[Luminiferous aether]] was a hypothetical medium believed to be necessary for the transmission of electromagnetic energy. It was proved nonexistent by the [[Michelson-Morley experiment]] in 1887. {{wpcite|Luminiferous aether}} |
* [[Elan vital]] was a hypothetical substance which infused living matter and caused it to move as consciously directed, as well as being necessary for [[evolution]]. {{wpcite|Elan vital}} | * [[Elan vital]] was a hypothetical substance which infused living matter and caused it to move as consciously directed, as well as being necessary for [[evolution]]. {{wpcite|Elan vital}} | ||
| Line 15: | Line 19: | ||
===Further Reading=== | ===Further Reading=== | ||
* '''2007-08-25''' [http://lesswrong.com/lw/iu/mysterious_answers_to_mysterious_questions/ Mysterious Answers to Mysterious Questions] by Eliezer Yudkowsky | * '''2007-08-25''' [http://lesswrong.com/lw/iu/mysterious_answers_to_mysterious_questions/ Mysterious Answers to Mysterious Questions] by Eliezer Yudkowsky | ||
| + | {{links/smw}} | ||
Latest revision as of 13:19, 3 August 2021
About
A fake explanation is anything which sounds like an explanation, or is offered as an explanation, but which does not offer any further understanding even if it might be true.
Many fake explanations are also curiosity stoppers.
Examples
- "Because God did it" is one example commonly used in religion-based arguments.
- The question-and-answer pair "What makes it go? Energy!", found in an elementary school science textbook, was derided by the late Nobel Prize-winning physicist Richard Feynman as being utterly useless as an explanation.
- Phlogiston was a hypothetical substance contained within certain materials and whose release was believed to explain processes such as combustion and the rusting of metals, which are now understood as oxidation. [W]
- Luminiferous aether was a hypothetical medium believed to be necessary for the transmission of electromagnetic energy. It was proved nonexistent by the Michelson-Morley experiment in 1887. [W]
- Elan vital was a hypothetical substance which infused living matter and caused it to move as consciously directed, as well as being necessary for evolution. [W]
Links
Reference
- 2007-08-20 Fake Explanations by Eliezer Yudkowsky
Further Reading
- 2007-08-25 Mysterious Answers to Mysterious Questions by Eliezer Yudkowsky