2004-02-15 Homosexual Marriage and Civilization/analysis

Index to Sections

• 01 : (introduction) [add precis]
• 02 : Marriage Is Already Open to Everyone [add precis]
• 03 : Marrying Is Hard to Do [add precis]
• 04 : The War On Marriage [add precis]
• 05 : Marriage Is Everybody's Business [add precis]
• 06 : Civilization Is Rooted in Reproductive Security [add precis]
• 07 : Balancing Family and Society [add precis]
• 08 : America's Anti-Family Experiment [add precis]
• 09 : Humpty Has Struck Before OSC states as fact that the hetero-binary-nuclear family is the only type of family that is really a family, and other family-types are not actually families. (redefining "family")
• 10 : The Propaganda Mill «anyone who tries to teach children to aspire to create a child-centered family with a father and a mother will be labeled as a bigot and accused of hate speech.» Sounds so unfair, doesn't it.
• 11 : Loss of Trust [add precis]
• 12 : They Think They Have the Power [add precis]
• 13 : Response to Letter [add precis]

Outlines

01 : (introduction) (outline)

1. Allowing homosexuals to "marry" would:
   1. change the definition of "marry"
   2. represent a sweeping change to (American) society
   3. not be supported by the Constitution
   4. be yet another potentially devastating social experiment
      1. ...without any prior examination of the possible effects
      2. ...without any attempt to determine if American citizens want whatever effects seem likely
2. "The Left" is trying to make this happen against the will of the American citizenry

02 : Marriage Is Already Open to Everyone (outline)

1. Gays are already free to marry opposite-sex partners, and are therefore not currently being discriminated against.
2. In order to claim discrimination, they have to change the definition of "marriage".
3. Society does not benefit in any way from labeling the bonding of homosexual lovers as "marriage".

03 : Marrying Is Hard to Do (outline)

1. The social need for man-woman unions is apparently very strong:
   • Men and women naturally segregate from each other
   • And yet the union of a man and a woman has been a cultural imperative for all of human history
2. Children learn their sex roles from the parent which matches their sex
3. The Left would like to see the learning of sex roles break down (which is why they support gay marriage)
4. If the breakdown in learning of sex roles causes problems, The Left will use this as a pretext to further break down the family

04 : The War On Marriage (outline)

• Marriage is in the process of being systematically destroyed.
• This is evidenced by the dramatic increase in divorces and the number of children who are born out of wedlock and grow up without a father.
• This destruction has been going on for two generations.
• The lives of children who grow up with one parent missing are "deformed"
• Growing up with one parent missing is worse than growing up poor, even if you have plenty of money
• When one parent is missing, it is usually the father
• Only fathers can:
  • laying down the groundwork for a sense of moral judgment
  • give praise that is believable
    • believable praise is necessary for genuine self-confidence
• Concession: some marriages are bad for the kids, and some divorced parents are able to raise kids jointly
• ...but most kids would rather have both parents at home
• Most kids would prefer that parents acquire the strength or maturity to change their behaviors so no divorce would be necessary

05 : Marriage Is Everybody's Business (outline)

[add outline]

06 : Civilization Is Rooted in Reproductive Security (outline)

[add outline]

07 : Balancing Family and Society (outline)

[add outline]

08 : America's Anti-Family Experiment (outline)

[add outline]

09 : Humpty Has Struck Before (outline)

[add outline]

10 : The Propaganda Mill (outline)

[add outline]

11 : Loss of Trust (outline)

[add outline]

12 : They Think They Have the Power (outline)

[add outline]

13 : Response to Letter (outline)

[add outline]